Search This Blog

Showing posts with label Church. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Church. Show all posts

Wednesday, November 8, 2023

We Want Satan, and We Ain't Waitin'! Ohio and Kentucky's vote

Friends,

Vox populum: We want Satan and we ain't waitin'!

The notion of collective punishment revisited. 

Regarding the November 7 election: If I still resided in Ohio, I'd leave. 

God was not exactly mocked in this latest election – more like utterly ignored. And note this wasn't the case of some idiot judge somewhere who had absolutely no idea of embryology, genetics, or even metaphysics and natural law. This involved instead a majority vote of the Ohio demos for the devotees of Moloch, a.k.a. Satan, to damn all and sundry in the entire state.

That's mob rule, a.k.a. "democracy". Kinda like Original Sin. Everyone gets to be damned, you see? Unless God is particularly merciful on Judgment Day. And unless we bend over backwards to earn that mercy through prayer, fasting, and good works. No "cheap grace" this round. No Lutheran snow on a dunghill or Calvin's pre-predestination warm glow inside. The Ohio vote bore a collective out-and-proud affirmation that "We want Satan and we ain't waitin'!"

The forces of evil won in Ohio on November 7 via popular vote. They even voted in "recreational marijuana use". 24th state to do so. Great. Get stoned so you cannot notice Hell opening for you.
  1. In the American context, the old way of putting this was vox populum, vox Dei. The voice of the people is the voice of God. I.e. final authority, the ultimate judge. Public opinion, solely, is God.
  2. To which Ohioan General Sherman wryly commented, "Vox populum, vox humbug." ("Humbug" being a 19th century version of something much sharper today.) 
  3. They want to damn us with collective guilt, much like Israel is applying to the Gazans. Most Gazans probably strongly support Hamas, but whether they do or not, the Israelis are applying collective punishment. Truly, the wages of sin is death. Romans 6:23
  4. Democracy implies as we benefit collectively from the actions of the majority, so the actions of the majority can damn us collectively.
Lot and Sodom
Let me solemnly assure you that Lot was saved from Sodom SOLELY because Abraham was his uncle. That's it. But a damnation resulted anyway, because Lot had chosen to live in Sodom. He had a free choice. Could have separated from Abraham and then lived most anywhere. But nope, the dope chose Sodom, which archaeology has clearly identified in Jordan northeast of the Dead Sea: a site called Tell el-Hamman. (See the videos of Dr. Steven Collins.) Collective punishment followed Lot. So, Lot's wife looked back and died and later in a cave his daughters committed unspeakable (and unthinkable) sin with him to found two bastardized "nations" of imbeciles. One daughter turned out to be the mother of what would become Moab, a hopeless pagan enemy of Israel (yet God saw to it that the nation of Moab eventually produced after many generations one Ruth, who became an ancestress of Our Lord.) What happened to Lot after that, though? Vanished from history. In inexpressible shame.

Kentucky meanwhile voted to keep its Democrat governor, who will take the first opportunity to lock the people down and force them to wear masks in the next fraudulent "plandemic". Democrats have never left off being slave masters. He'll support the national Democrats in stopping next year's election (don't think for a moment that that isn't coming!) I thought Kentuckians were smarter than that. Was I ever wrong. 

What about the Church?
I've read where the bishops of Ohio didn't campaign too diligently against the referendum. When have American bishops ever? 
  1. The bishops are Siamese Twins with the Democrat Party, and today live off the largess of the Federal government paying them to manage all the illegal hordes (er, excuse me: "refugees") flooding the nation. 
  2. They could have stopped abortion in its tracks back in 1973 by excommunicating any politician, starting with Ted Kennedy, who promoted abortion. 
  3. Don't bishops know they have supernatural power? 
  4. Don't they know exorcists can make demons scream and howl just by showing the devils a photo of the local bishop? 
  5. Regarding Soros and all those financing this pro-Abort vote, the bishops could at least recite at Holy Mass the "cursing" psalms of 68:20-29 (Psalm 69 in the Jewish Masoretic/Protestant numbering) and 108/109, and others. 
  6. So, they did little or nothing? Whether true or not, we needed a Fr. Altman in every parish and seated on every bishop's cathedra. Instead, they cancel him.
  7. The FBI and Deep State will shut the Church down anyway; might as well go down fighting.
And please believe me when I say that Fr James Altman was and is quite right that a Catholic cannot vote for a Democrat. Democrats have not only gone full abortionist, they've gone full communist. (Someone recently wrote that if you don't believe that, look up the Democrat's national website and then look up the Communist Party USA's website and try to find any differences.)
  • Being part of a "democratic" governance makes each of us responsible for what happens, and certainly a Catholic who votes for a Democrat (or a pro-Abortion "RINO") has put a millstone around their neck, one they don't usually feel, though deep down I think they know what they've done.
  • God knows exactly what they've done and will confront them with it when it is too late for them to "change their mind" because in Eternity, one experiences the "Boundless Now" as Boethius described it, and it is too late to change one's damnation.
The Secular Explanation
In terms of secular politics, the general consensus is that "Big Money" from outside of the state bought the vote for abortion in Ohio. No doubt. Many George Soros types exist, and as Elon Musk says, Soros clearly hates humanity. Butchering babies is as inhuman as it gets. (He definitely needs a psalm read against him.) But Ohioans have to be so utterly heartless as to not care, for surely they now ALL know what abortion is and what it does. Therefore they tar all Ohioans as pro-Aborts by association: Ohio, the place where abortion RULES. And now where parents cannot stop their children from mutilating themselves.

As I say, because we can vote, when the vote is for evil, we all get tarred with that sticky sulfur-stinking offal. Myself, as well. Of course, I had requested an absentee ballot and my county Board of Elections sent it to me and I marked it to turn down the proposal, but as noted, the vote was widely in favor of adopting the amendment. Naturally, the sacraments will wash off the carrion, but we have to be ever more scrupulous in our spiritual lives because now all Hell (literally) has us in its armpit until the Tribulation – which I think has begun – runs its course.

Truly, in the words of St. Paul, we need to work out our salvation in fear and trembling. Philippians 2:12-13

I think I shall listen to Tallis. Lamentations of Jeremiah.

  An Préachán


Tuesday, March 22, 2022

Part II Dr. Bryan Ardis accuses Catholic Church of running the Covid Scam

Friends, 

Part II on Dr. Bryan Ardis

Sunday, February 10, 2019

The Crisis of Masculinity in the church

So much of what is going on is a result of this culture's crisis of masculinity. The Church seems to have few masculine men in leadership positions. Bishop Schneider is one such. American Bishop Joseph Strickland of Tyler, Texas, is another. But very few of our shepherds are men in the traditional sense.

What all this blather about "diversity of religions" being "the will of God" is septic tank overflow, sure, but it is feministic septic tank overflow. The true feminine spirit is reconciling, tries to defuse tense situations and comforts everybody; being "motherly" -- but that is native to it. Yet that is not something men should be trying to imitate, and certainly not emulate. A man's man would stand up to Cuomo, for example, or have that utter reprobate McCarrick literally thrown out on his ear, into the gutter where he belongs. (Well, that bum is dangerous and should be locked up with the key thrown away.)

But instead we get prelates, from Our Caudillo on down, who act the role of an emasculated, feminized man imitating what he thinks women would do. Hence we get Francis' endless slop about "Mercy" instead of clear, no-nonsense teaching and discipline regarding every mortal sin and yet, so oddly, Bergoglio is petty and vindictive, like a "bad girl" in a snooty Girls' School ragging on a student who doesn't fit into her clique. A sort of "Lady of the Flies" instead of "Lord of the Flies." And it is in that sense, the Vat2 word "pastoral" is code for doing nothing to a Cuomo or a McCarrick -- or for that matter, to a pope.

It's disgusting, but it is something found across the culture.

An Préachán

Monday, July 16, 2018

A Response to Bill Donohue About that Wretch, Theodore McCarrick

Catholic League president Bill Donohue recently wrote a response to the revelations about Cardinal McCarrick. The well-known defender of the Church (via the Catholic League) wrote, in part:
A little over a year after assuming the reins of the Catholic League, I started exchanging letters with Newark Archbishop Theodore McCarrick. He was genuinely supportive of our efforts. On October 17, 1994, he wrote to me saying, “I have been speaking to the bishops of New Jersey at our Provincial meeting and encouraging them to support the work of the Catholic League in their own dioceses.”

Now he is bearing a heavy cross. The takeaway for me is clear. ...
Mr Donohue goes on to write what I suppose would be considered a muted and sympathetic essay in Christian charity, and ends by asking us to pray for Cardinal McCarrick.

Very nice, but utterly deficient.

Why? Because: Enough of this obscenity is enough, and we're long past "enough".

First of all, Mr Donohue has no way of knowing whether a congenital liar like McCarrick (who lied for decades about what he was "into", and who lied to all and sundry, up to and including a man the current pope has canonized: John Paul II) could remotely be "genuinely supportive of our efforts". Lying and falsely representing themselves is the essential problem with homosexual clerics: one has no way of knowing how honest they are about anything. Their lives are a lie, and they lie to cover that reality up.

The Homosexual Rape of the Church
Sin makes you stupid, or as Aquinas put it, "Sin darkens the intellect." In McCarrick's case – and in the case of all homosexuals in the clergy – sin makes liars of them as well, or they would have never been allowed into the clergy in the first place. They falsely represented themselves to get in, or had older homosexuals let them in, for "favors".

Liars, and thieves, too, they are: thieves spiritual, thieves physical (rape, molestation) and thieves of ecclesiastical reputation. They've destroyed the reputation of the Catholic Church. It will take 500 years of extremely serious efforts by all the clergy to even remotely begin to restore the Church's reputation. And homosexuality has devastated Church morale. It is incredible (in a literal sense) how devastated Church morale is by these perverts, worming their way into the vitals of the Church, like maggots or parasites. (They've gutted the "Vatican II" Church, certainly, and hastened its collapse.) Were the Church not divinely inspired and sustained, truly, it would die. Read the disgust and anguish of Michael Brendan Dougherty here, for an example:

An excerpt:
There is an undeniable psychological tension between my religious belief that I cannot have hope for salvation outside the visible, institutional Church and my honest conviction that of all the institutions and societies that intersect with my life, the Church is by far the most corrupt, the most morally lax, the most disillusioning, and the most dangerous for my children. In that tension, personal prayer will dry up like dew at noon.
That's how bad this situation is. But let us put it in historical perspective:
  • The Protestant Reformation has been with us 500 years. It has gone a long way – via the "Vatican II Church" and the alterations of the Mass and all our other devotions – in turning the modern Catholic Church into a Protestant denomination (despite occasional claims otherwise).
  • Islam has been with us 1400 years. It, too, is the "gift that keeps on giving". 
  • And now we have a homosexual mafia burrowed into the heart of the Church, a true parasite apparently resisting every effort to remove it.
Make no mistake about any of them. All three of these crucifixions directly attack the central Christian revelation of the Incarnation.
  • Islam is Christianity's "kill shot", denying the Incarnation root and branch, insisting that God is one person, not three, let alone not allowing one of them incarnating Himself to save us from sin.
  • Protestantism accepts the Incarnation, certainly, but takes the reason for it away. All one has to do is call on the Lord and one is saved, having accepted God as one's Savior. (Romans 10:13; the most Protestant verse in the Bible).
  • But Protestantism teaches this salvation requires no change of one's nature. We are, as Luther said, Simul Justus et Peccator, simultaneously justified before God but also still a sinner, or as he metaphorically put it, we are each a manure pile covered with snow, the snow being God's grace and the manure pile our permanent human (fallen) nature. (This is, of course, grotesque; see C.S. Lewis' questioning of this teaching in his 10th Letter to Malcolm, in Letters to Malcolm, Chiefly on Prayer, for one example of a push back against the notion.)
  • This foundational Protestant idea denies the New Testament doctrine that Christians are now a new creation in Christ, that our nature is changed; indeed, that we are "born again" by the Holy Spirit through baptism and reception of the Most Holy Eucharist, which changes our nature through what the Greeks call theosis, and the West, Divinization. For example:
·   St. Athanasius: "For the Son of God became man so that we might become God." (De inc. 54, 3: PG 25, 192B) and [CCC 460]
·   St. Thomas Aquinas: "The only-begotten Son of God, wanting to make us sharers in his divinity, assumed our nature, so that he, made man, might make men gods." (Opusc. 57, 1-4) [CCC 460]
·   This teaching is stated in many ways throughout the New Testament. Examples:
·   John 1:12 “But to all who received him, who believed in his name, he gave power to become children of God; 13 who were born, not of blood nor of the will of the flesh nor of the will of man, but of God.” (Obviously, a new creation)
·   2 Cor 5:17, “Therefore, if anyone is in Christ, the new creation has come: The old has gone, the new is here!” (Again, a new creation) 2 Peter 1:4 might well put it best; see also Romans, 6:4, 7:6, 12:2; Galatians 3:27; Ephesians 4:22-24; Colossians 3:8-12.
  • It is because of this change in our nature that Catholicism has always been adamantly set against sin. Sin can have no place in a Christian's life, as St. Paul teaches throughout his writings. (Example: 1 Cor 6:9-11) But because the modern (and Modernist) Church is essentially Protestant – Luther famously wrote that he could sin many times a day and it not affect his assurance of salvation – it now teaches that we cannot live up to the moral law, and must accept moral failure and yet have no fear of our salvation, because the Church essentially now accepts Simul Justus et Peccator.
What Homosexuality Demands
Now, what homosexuality does is to create a third cross for Christianity to bear: whereas Islam denies the Incarnation essentially, and Protestantism denies the Incarnation as necessary for our theosis, and denies theosis essentially, so "GayChurch" now embraces "incarnation" in a wholly prurient, carnal, and libidinous sense: we are sex objects to violate. Isn't THAT what the homosexual clergy do? They violate: they violate their vows and the Ten Commandments as much as they violate altar boys and seminarians. And of these three crucifixions: denying the reality of the Incarnation, misunderstanding the salvic nature of the Incarnation, or literally buggering the Incarnation, which is obviously worse? (N.B. Traditional Arabic Islamic culture is one of the most homosexual on Earth, despite Koranic teaching; and Protestantism never had any relationship to homosexuality except to condemn it, until the latter 20th century when "mainline" Protestant Churches embraced it. More traditional types of Protestantism continue to reject it, of course. The Catholic Church is torn between these positions; Traditional Catholicism continues to uphold the ancient teaching, with Progressive Catholics going the mainline Protestant route.) 

So, therefore, with all this in mind and reminding everyone I am not God, and do not make final judgements on anyone's soul's eternal fate, I answer Mr Donohue thusly, (and certainly do not think it is "over the top"): Pray for Cardinal McCarrick? I myself pray for Cardinal McCarrick, alright. Indeed, in an utmost earnest fervor, I pray that he go to Hell quickly – if that is his destiny. I am not God and I cannot send him there, but he ought to go. Few deserve it more. Why? He has spent decades upon decades lying, bearing false witness, coveting the bodies of young men in his charge, imposing himself on them, perhaps murdering their salvation, and blaspheming and directly insulting God Himself, all Three Persons, but especially the Second and Third. (Allegations that these evils were few in number or long ago are irrelevant: it happened, and it no doubt happened many more times than reported; and McCarrick lied about it for decades.) Theodore McCarrick is a soul vampire, an undead who recreates his hideousness in the young men he's violated.

Dante put homosexuals in the Seventh Circle of Hell, below even murderers and suicides. Considering what McCarrick and those like him have done over long lives, it is, simply, quite apropos.

He can go join "Franny" Spellmen in the bottom of the seventh circle of Hell. At least he won't lack for company.

N.B. Not I do not say McCarrick is unforgivable. Were he to "come out" and admit all, instead of hiding behind the Church's lawyers, as he is doing right now – were he to "name names" and finally, for once in a long life of soul-damning deceit, be honest – maybe he can avoid the serious possibility of Hell that he now faces. But don't hold your breath. "Sin darkens the intellect", indeed. And the last thing the GayChurch wants is true conversion.

An Préachán

Monday, July 9, 2018

Admonish the (Modernist) Sinner

When you meet someone calling you "racist", respond with "baby killer". When they explode the first time, say, "You support abortion, right? Abortion kills three times as many black babies as white, so you're both racist and a baby killer."

Something similar needs to be done here regarding these non-Catholic Catholics. "Not Catholic!" I guess would be the comment to anyone promoting gays in the priesthood, or womyn priests (priestesses) or whatever it might be, such as Liberation Church. "Not Catholic." If they go after you with some sort of  rejoinder to "Not Catholic!", just say, "The Church existed for 1963 years without teaching what it does now. The majority of bishops and priests in the world still hold and teach the traditional Catholic Faith. I'm with them, not you. The Not Catholic, you."

Something like that. I write this both because it is time to "admonish the sinner" and because the time for reasoning with these intellectual louts, these spiritual thugs, is over. 60 years of Vat2 and now Bergoglio, and it's obvious who the sinners are, and they need admonished. Their spiritual bullying stops now, too, and stops first in our our spirits.

RC

Wednesday, December 27, 2017

Cri de cœur from One Peter Five's founder about the current state of the Church

I tend to be perhaps too optimistic at times. But there's always One Peter Five to bring me back the earth of our realities, as it were. Here Steve Skojec whips up a true Cri de Coeur about the current state of Holy Church.


The Comments are good, too.


How bad are things in the Church, though, really? Pretty awful. You may think Steve is overdoing it, but he isn't. However, being the phlegmatic character that I am, somehow I'm not losing sleep over it. No matter how bad things get, after all, we (Catholics and Orthodox) still have enough validly ordained priests around confecting the sacraments that God is truly with us in the Real Presence. That's better than the Protestants and their Real Absence. 

But they're suffering miserably, as well. Apostasy is in the air: the state is pagan, Gays are in your face, and Islam is at the gates. The time for blasé Catholicism has past; the time for heroic Catholicism has come.



There's always hope. And we've always prayer. So, get to it.

Otherwise, it's back to the beginning, actually. Lions, burning stakes. Nero. Caligula. Only we've got Islam to contend with this time around.





As Yogi Bera famously said, it's "deja vu all over again".


Happy New Year.


An Préachán

Monday, October 2, 2017

Fr Dwight Longenecker and the Perils of the Quicksand Middle…Part II

Part II



This ought to be simple: To be a Catholic theologian is to use your intellect and spiritual life to relate the timeless teachings of the Church to the specific time in which you live. The current-day denizens of this sad age are desperate for the Truth. They’re desperate for the Truth and True Spirituality. 

  • Where a Bergoglio stresses “mercy” or even “healing”, it ought to be obvious that no one will ask for either if they think they don’t need it; if, for example, that “Gay is okay” or marriage is something to leave if you’re bored or if euthanasia – what is it but simply: “Old? Sick? Then die!”

Theologians should be promoting Truth and True Spirituality instead of changing them to fit this wretched age of moral Lilliputians. Too many modern theologians pervert the Church’s timeless teaching to match the contemporary banality we suffer through. They’re as morally confused as Karl Rahner.
Poor Fr Longenecker writes, “Critics of propositional faith believe that, at best, the propositions are simply a framework or structure of belief, and that the real experience is far more complicated, but also far more exciting and real.”
“Real”? C’mon, Father. “REAL”? If the theologians whom you describe think that way, they’re the blind leading the blind. These “propositions” are the dogmas of the Faith, the bolts that hold it together! So if you want to write clearly about this subject, toss out the theologians’ Alinksy tag and call them dogmas. They’re the black-and-white “bottom line” of what it’s all about. That’s because today’s “real experience” in sin is no different than it was in the pagan Roman Empire. Well, I suppose you could let the technology dazzle you, but underneath all our gadgets, which most people have no clue how they actually work and can’t possibly repair them when the civilization crashes, but underneath all that, we’re the same people as those Ur, of Sodom, of St. Paul’s Corinth or St. Peter’s Roma!
Fr Dwight continues, “They (these modern theologians) criticize those who like a propositional faith as being rigid, legalistic or Pharisaical.” Ah, yes. The pope does that ad nauseum. “The critics of propositional faith like to emphasize the more subjective ‘encounter with Christ.’ They advocate getting away from all the debates about doctrine or canon law, rolling up one’s sleeves and getting busy doing God’s work in the world.”
Do they? Their position is pathetic. How so?
  • You say that that is “subjective” and so it is! How can these critics remotely know what “God’s work in the world” is if they don’t have clear-cut, strong, “propositions”, a.k.a. DOGMAS and Doctrines (“dogma” just the Greek for “doctrine”).
  • These doctrines are fundamental to how we approach both God and each other because they explain who we are, Who and What God is, what our nature is after the Fall and God’s prescription for a cure, His long-running Covenantal Plan for our salvation.
  • These dogmas define the Faith, they’re the religion’s DNA.
  • Without every priest and theologian and bishop (and even a large portion of the laity) being absolutely STEEPED in these “propositions”, there’s no way on God’s Earth we CAN do “God’s work” for we wouldn’t know what it is.
And that's the Vatican II Church in a nutshell. It avoids all that. It avoids the nuts and bolts of the religion. It avoids the beauty of it and the shock, the demands of Christ which He makes on every page of the Gospel you never hear it talking about. What is the modern Church doing? Prattling on about propositions instead of dogmas, worshiping in a brain-locked 1970's style polyester pastel liturgy, and its major theologians are either crazy in love with old ladies (review all the weirdness Rahner felt and did for his untouchable "love", who would not give up her abbot lover – if he even existed), or waiting for the next supposed "revelation" from a woman seer, as did von Balthasar. 
Fr Dwight’s column is quite long and he tries to cover the bases, as it were, but he doesn't go into ANY detail about how goofy the theologians have been who lambast "propositional faith". Yet he finally does come back around again to some degree of support for “Propositional” Catholics, referring to them as the trellis upon which the vines of fruitful Gospel love bears rich harvest. He writes, “My own take on this, therefore, is that I understand the need for the ‘encounter with Christ’ as opposed to a faith that is merely propositional, but I also believe that without a clear affirmation of the propositions of our faith, the ‘encounter with Christ’ becomes no more than a subjective religious experience. Both are needed….”
(Head smack.) Yes, if by "subjective religious experience" you mean a taste of the Spiritual Reality all around us, yes, yes. But you should be definitely saying Mass in such a way that encourages that: and the "Novus Ordo" doesn't do so. 
As for "encounters with Christ"...ah, yes. The Protestant “Encounter with Christ”. Well, though not raised a Protestant, I grew up with them, and I know any number who “encountered Christ” and then “disencountered” Him later. All hat and no cattle? Perhaps. 
  • Protestantism is deeply, mortally flawed for a host of reasons – let's be honest here – but aside from its rejection of the Church's authority, which has left it in incoherence, in some 20,000 odd denominations – its basic problem: it is mnemonic. 
  • For Protestantism, Christ is a memory, long Ascended. Oh, He can send you a warm feeling now and again (Calvin taught you knew you were saved when you felt a warm glow in your innards).
  • He's not here now (except in spirit when two or three are gathered in His name: (Matthew 18:20)... 
  • Whereas in Catholicism, Christ is metaphysically present. He's really here, Body and Blood. THAT's a TRUE "Encounter with Christ" and it is profoundly liturgical, meaning a formal act of worship in which the veil between Earth and Heaven is drawn back, and Reality is truly present to us, as it will be in Heaven (the Book of Revelation describes the liturgy of Heaven).
  • Yet of course the Church since Vatican II has eschewed all that for, well, Protestantism. 
  • I mean, it's gone the route of the mainline Protestant Churches in terms of worship, and has thus lots massive amounts of its laity (and religious), as they themselves have. 
  • Thus now we're lamely talking up "encounters with Christ" without the proverbial clue.
Fr Dwight then tries to explain Bergoglio’s dereliction of duty thus: “In other words, he does not answer his critics because he does not wish to play their game. He does not wish to be drawn into their legalistic arguments, but instead wants to continue to challenge them.”
Change “challenge” there, Father Longenecker, to “insult” or “ridicule” or “disparage,” and you’ve got it.
It ain’t no game, Father Longenecker. The authors of the Dubia and all these various critics you detail in the first third of your column are not playing a “game” and they’re not being “legalistic”. And Jorge Bergoglio isn’t “challenging” them, he’s stepping all over them, shoving them down hard into the mucky quicksand, face first. We’re “bead counters” he has said, and “rabbits”, and God knows what else he’s called us. For a POPE to call the pious, the devout, such names, is a rank abomination. It sure doesn’t show any good will on his part, to put it mildly. It literally drips spiritual arrogance and radiates “virtue signaling” of a narcissistic poseur.
The basic job of any pope is not to somehow “challenge the belief” of the core Church, those who love the ancient Mass and devotions. It is NOT to be a theologian or evangelist, either, actually, any more than a rock star or emperor: it’s to be a Rock. The Rock. Basic solid pavement upon which the Truth stands against the ages. An unbreakable foundation. The pope's job is to guard the Deposit of Faith and help his brother bishops stand tall and bear the Gospel through all the horrors of this vale of tears. The buck stops with the pope, and this is why. He, at least, cannot stand on quicksand. He has the final call because he has this “rock duty”, and he has it precisely because the Church Militant needs such a top umpire on Earth.
Pope Francis is not doing that job. He’s embracing heretics and deviants and tossing the pious, the dévotes, as they were called during Richelieu's time, to the wolves just as Richelieu did when he embraced the Swedes and heretical Germans and bankrupted France just to defeat the dévotes of the French court (Queen Anne) and to bring down the Habsburgs.
Jorge Bergoglio is our Cardinal Richelieu, and only God Himself can help us survive the disaster he’s foisted on us.
Fr Dwight says, ‟As a pastor I understand this and am sympathetic to what I believe Pope Francis is trying to do.” Okay. Well, we can disagree about what he’s trying to do, shall we? But just look at the mess around you. "By their works you will know them." (Matthew 7:16-20) So Pope Francis shall be judged. But in the meantime, that quicksand is getting soupier by the minute.

An Préachán

Saturday, September 2, 2017

The Church's Constitutional System and the Modernist War Against It


(Partly from a blog post I wrote for OnePeterFive)

We live in a time of Ecclesiastical troubles: The Church's system isn't working, clearly, but what is it, that system, exactly?

The Catholic Church's "constitution" is a three-legged support system, as is the U.S. Constitution's, curiously, except the U.S. Constitution stipulates the three supports of government are specifically designed to counter-balance each other, to be a self-correcting mechanism, whereas the Church's three supports: Holy Writ, Sacred Tradition, and the living Magisterium, are supposed to be MUTUALLY SUPPORTIVE.

Curiously enough, it is plain from the New Testament that the living Magisterium is the oldest of the three: what else is the Council of Jerusalem in Acts except the living Magisterium of that day meeting to decide an important issue? Then came Holy Scripture, written mostly by VIP's in the initial Magisterium: two epistles by St. Peter, head of the Apostles and Christ's Prime Minister of the New Israel (and one gospel by his secretary and amanuensis, John Mark, later bishop of the 2nd largest city of the empire, Alexandria), one by St. James, bishop and presider at the Jerusalem Council, which was held in his city, and the lion's share of the NT books were of course written by St. Paul, another VIP at the Council.



     Rembrandt's Paul the Apostle

It always dumbfounds me – and I grew up among Protestants, mostly rural Methodists and Lutherans – that Protestants just don't get this; apparently Baptists believe as a matter of essential Baptist dogma (haha, BAPTISTS having DOGMA? But they DO!) that the various attendees at the Council were just buddies and followers (or relatives) of the departed Jesus, and had no hierarchy in any sort of actual institutional "Church". But whatever. I make this point because nothing the current pope and the Modernists do is so shocking to me (I mean, what would one EXPECT Modernists to do but such stuff, right?) as how Protestants can call themselves Bible Christians and NOT get this.

Sacred Tradition came last, and is the "Constitutional Case Law) of the Magisterium living the Biblical teachings out over 2,000 years. The difference is: whereas the U.S. Supreme Court is not bound by case law (which is contrary to the original English law system ) the Magisterium IS bound by Sacred Tradition (and the Bible as understood via the decisions of past Magisteriums, i.e., Sacred Tradition).

The whole thing operates as a mutual support system. The living Magisterium has tons of "case law" to guide it and the pope has essentially carte blanc authority to legislate and enforce to support the Bible and Tradition. But naturally, were he to depart from supporting the other two legs of authority, then HIS authority evaporates: oh, he's still "pope" until some validly appoint Council removes him, but who would listen to or trust him?

Now first, I need to talk a little bit in political terms. Catholics (and others) often say they don't want politics and religion mixed, but here I am just talking about the nature of the U.S. Constitution, its Three Branches of Government, and not "politics" per se.


What we're dealing with today in the One, Holy, Catholic and Apostolic Church is that a specialized party (acting very much indeed like a political faction or party – and remember James Madison, author of the U.S. Constitution, LOATHED such!) has been working assiduously for over 100 years now to overturn the entire system. These are the Modernists, so called, also known today as Progressives. They organized originally to try to come up with a solution to a collapse of the Faith in Europe. The Intellectuals left Christianity (Prot or Catholic) in the 18th century, the working masses left if – or began to – in the 19th century for the new Christian heresy of Socialism. And then at the end of the 19th century, the middle classes began to show signs that they were leaving, too; i.e., the lose morals and "free thinking" and "Bohemian living" of the "Gay Nineties" was only put on hiatus by "The Great War" and reappeared in in the 1920s. Again on hiatus because of Fascism and Communism and World War II, it began again in the 1950s (Beatniks) and finally came into full flower in the infamous 1960s.

The Modernist solution to all this was to relax the moral teachings, their idea being that Christianity's moral strictures (Catholic or Protestant, but especially Catholic, which of course wouldn't allow divorce, etc.) was too strict for "Modern Man". They had various roots, often Protestant ones, such as the Tübingen School during the mid-19th century. Their ideas and personalities included:
  • Easing off on traditional morals. "Relativism" is a key word to understand their thinking (and remember that Benedict 16 condemned the "Dictatorship of Relativism" before he was forced out of office). "Relativism will keep people in church!" they essentially said. 
  • But naturally, to "ease off" on morals, one had to argue for relativism; i.e., everything is relative. To do that, they then had to do a lot of tinkering with the Church's authority structure and the roots of the Church in its origin; basically, all this was soon seen by the hierarchy as quite dangerous, as it could unravel the whole system. 
  • If one were to "ease off" on the morals, (relatively, if I may say it that way), for example, then one would have to "reinterpret" Sacred Scripture, and to reinterpret Sacred Scripture, one would have to negate, undo, and generally rewrite Church Tradition! It all would just avalanche out of control, in other words.  
  • Charles Darwin was an essential but indirect influence, naturally enough, because science seemed to be saying we were evolved from lower forms, and if so, then we could certainly "evolve" further and further: there could be no "baseline".
  • Adolf von Harnack (1851 – 1930) a liberal German Lutheran, was an influence.
  • His contemporary, Louis Duchesne (1843 – 1922), a Breton priest, polymath (linguist, archaeologist, historian, etc.) helped to influence the Modernists, and his Early History of the Christian Church was put on the Index of Forbidden Books in 1912. Duchesne was one influence on...
  • Alfred Loisy (1857 - 1940) who is considered a founder of the Modernists, and who argued Scriptural elements might be only metaphorically true, not literally true (a Baptist friend is always telling me Catholics read Biblical metaphor literally, for example), and
  • The Jesuit-influenced Bollandists, who were refounded about 1845: their research led to a lot of Vatican II ideas on the liturgy (though subsequent scholarship cast doubts on much of their work, Pope Francis still even today finds the time to praise them). 
  • Another Jesuit, the Dubliner George Tyrrell (1861 – 1909), is an interesting and sad case of a Modernist, and who sort of encapsulates the whole movement, as it were.
So Modernism had a lot of intellectuals involved in it. But Leo XIII worked to counter it, and Pius X tried to blast is out of existence in 1907. In Lamentabili Sane Exitu of that year (the finely phrased "A Lamentable Departure Indeed"), His Holiness condemned 65 Modernist ideas, and in his famous encyclical Pascendi dominici gregis (or "Feeding the Lord's Flock"), he described Modernism as the "synthesis of all heresies". Then he promulgated Sacrorum antistitum, an anti-Modernist oath all clerics had to take, and which of course the "spirit of Vatican II" abolished in 1967 when the Holy Office of that time, the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith (CDF) rescinded it. (Priests ordained in the Trad Orders often take it voluntarily, however.)

The next pope, Benedict XV, had his hands full because of WWI, and it wore him out. Pius XI, an exemplary pope, tried to combat both Communism and Fascism. So it was the next pope after him, Pius XII, who, after WWII, tried to put the brakes on some budding Modernist-type theologians, such as Henri de Lubac, by putting some of his writings on the Index. It pretty much tells you all you need to know that John Paul II made de Lubac a cardinal!

After that, a series of weak popes simply didn't understand what they were dealing with; however, Pius XII started the earthquake by letting some "liturgical reformers", including the infamous devotee of Ba'al (Hannibal) Bugnini loose in the Vatican's "Deep State"; also, Pius didn't assiduously appoint orthodox, young, highly intelligent cardinals during the last decade of his life: thus, when the Conclave that met in October 1958 to vote on his successor, its cardinals had a very small pool to choose from.

With that, the ball began rolling down the bowling alley toward the long-standing pins of Catholic dogma. "Cry havoc! And let slip the Modernists of War!"
  1. Starting with poor John 23, who was honestly too old and not vigorous enough to manage a Council, so the Modernists organized and simply took it from him (this is a well-known, exhaustively researched bit of history, btw)...
  2. Then the "Weeping Pope Hamlet" Paul 6, who was trying to be a supporter of the Progs but ultimately horrified at where they wanted to go...
  3. Then poor Albino Luciani, who might well have died of fright. 
  4. Karol Wojtyla was an amazing Nazi-era survivor and hero against Communism, a wonderful world evangelizer but a prelate who steadfastly held to Vat 2 principles – which were innately bad (the foundational thesis of all Traditionalists is that whatever the merits of Vatican II's documents, their over-all effect and many of their specific teachings are, sadly, actually bad doctrines and need to be excised). Because of JPII's reliance on Vat2, then, and unavoidably – since they're teachings are defective, resulted in his downfall – they left him a very bad Church manager because he "didn't get it"; i.e., I mean that while occasionally he appointed a good bishop, he also steadfastly appointed Progressive Modernists to important sees (can anyone say Cardinal Archbishop Bergoglio? I once read where Bishop Fabian Bruskewitz told JPII to his face that he was appointing bad bishops!) The sex scandal, which grew on JPII's watch, and finally the infamous, depraved debacle of the Legionnaires of Christ, killed him. 
  5. And finally we had the deeply intelligent and subtle theologian, Josef Ratzinger. In his early days, he was an ardent Vat2 reformer, but of the "milder" Cummunio faction (along with Henri de Lubac and Hans Urs von Balthasar, and thus an enemy of the rival "Terminator reformer school" known as the Concilium coven...er, school (these two groups were named for competing theological journals that published the papers of the two factions) that consisted of that old fornicator Karl Rahner, and Edward Schillebeeckx, and the infamously hyper-boring Hans Küng. 
So, to sum up: I think Pope Benedict 16 knew VERY well what was going on, but the Modernists' long-term War of Position (i.e., working incrementally and unnoticed to put their own supporters in important places in the hierarchy) left him in a strategically bad place: when they went to an open War of Maneuver against him (and I firmly believe they did so with Obama's help), they brought him down.
I pray that understanding this past and present background can, along with the inspiration of the Holy Ghost, help us to deal as effectively as we can with this ecclesiastical mess we find ourselves in.

An Préachán